Lot 5 Emerges as Treasure Trove of History
Oak Island, long shrouded in legend, has once again captured the world’s attention. In the latest season of The Curse of Oak Island, the Lagina brothers and their team uncovered a series of breathtaking discoveries on Lot 5 — artifacts that may connect the island not only to 17th-century French settlers but also to the enigmatic Knights Templar.
Among the findings: four ancient coins traced back to civilizations as far-reaching as Rome and India, a French ornamental chest strap, and a network of tunnels suggesting large-scale operations predating the infamous Money Pit.
French Relics and Templar Connections
Treasure hunter Gary Drayton’s metal detector led to the discovery of a decorated strap with a bow tie design — confirmed to be French in origin and once used on wooden chests. The artifact echoes earlier discoveries such as the lead cross, traced to southern France, fueling speculation of Templar voyages to the island centuries before European settlement.
Historian Zena Halpern’s controversial Templar map, allegedly drawn between the 12th and 14th centuries, gains new weight in light of these findings. Could Oak Island have been a hiding ground for sacred Templar relics?
Coins from Across Civilizations
Numismatist Sandy Campbell, with over 40 years of expertise, analyzed the coins from Lot 5. The collection includes:
-
Roman coins more than 2,000 years old.
-
A 6th–8th century Indian coin, suggesting trade far beyond Europe.
-
English, Spanish, and even Chinese pieces, widening the island’s mysterious web of connections.
Campbell’s analysis revealed one coin contained traces of gold, another bore depictions from pre-Christian times, and a third stood out as the largest coin ever discovered on Oak Island. Each find adds weight to theories of ancient expeditions and lost cargo routes.
Lot 8: Ox Shoes, Pathways, and Garnets
Parallel digs on Lot 8 yielded an ox shoe in excellent condition, stone-paved pathways, and an oval chain link believed to transport heavy chests. Most striking was a garnet gemstone that Freemason Scott Clark believes could be tied to the Knights Templar and even the Ark of the Covenant.
The evidence suggests organized operations moved vast cargo across the island — not the work of random settlers, but of groups with resources and purpose.
Hidden Tunnels and Ancient Pottery
Sonic drilling in Lot 5 uncovered soft zones and a possible collapsed chamber, hinting at man-made tunnels beneath the surface. Archaeologists also discovered redware pottery with unusual glaze, dating to the 17th and 18th centuries, raising questions about activity long before the Money Pit’s legend began.
Meanwhile, diver Tony Sampson’s underwater survey revealed a carved plank, fragments of blue-decorated pottery, clay pipes, and a silver coin — all pointing toward either a shipwreck or early colonial presence.
Theories: From Templars to Sir William Phips
The artifacts have reignited debate among historians. Some point to Sir William Phips, the 17th-century treasure hunter tied to Spanish plunder, while others see growing evidence of a direct Templar link.
Marty Lagina noted striking similarities between the discoveries and regions in Portugal known for Templar settlements, suggesting Oak Island may have been part of a secret transatlantic operation.
What Lies Ahead?
As Season 12 progresses, the Oak Island team shows no sign of slowing down. With Roman coins, French relics, and underground anomalies converging, the Lagina brothers believe they are closer than ever to uncovering the truth behind the island’s greatest mystery.
For now, Oak Island continues to whisper its secrets, each discovery another piece of a puzzle that has captivated treasure hunters for more than two centuries.
